The Future of Search: Preparing for New Competition from AI

Google is now facing a challenge that many once thought unimaginable; the potential decline of its Search traffic. New AI-powered platforms like Gemini and ChatGPT are emerging as strong competitors, and recent internal documents reveal that Google is preparing for this shift.

The Growing Role of AI in Search

Google has long been the go-to platform for search queries, and it’s hard to imagine a world where that’s no longer the case. But AI-driven innovations—such as AI Overviews, AI Mode, and the Gemini platform—have started to change how people search for information online. While Google continues to evolve and add AI features, executives are acknowledging that this transformation could lead to a decline in traffic for their traditional search platform.

Current State of Google Search Traffic

While there has not yet been a significant decline in Google Search traffic, there are clear signs that the landscape is changing. Google still dominates the search market, with billions of daily queries and substantial ad revenue. However, AI-powered tools like ChatGPT and Gemini are starting to attract users who prefer conversational, direct answers to search results. This shift, though in its relatively early stages, could affect the amount of traffic Google retains from traditional search in the future.

Recent data reveals a noticeable decline in traditional search engine usage. For instance, ChatGPT now commands approximately 80% of the AI search traffic, leaving competitors like DeepSeek and Google's Gemini trailing with single-digit percentages. This shift is further evidenced by a 2% year-over-year drop in Google's search traffic, as reported by Similarweb.

Moreover, Apple's senior vice president of services, Eddy Cue, stated that Google searches within Safari declined for the first time in 22 years, attributing this change to the increasing use of AI-powered tools like ChatGPT and Perplexity.

For now, Google continues to see growth in revenue from Search, but executives are aware of the growing competition from AI-driven platforms. This acknowledgment is reflected in recent internal meetings where executives discussed the potential for losing search traffic either to Gemini or ChatGPT. Google has not yet lost a substantial amount of traffic, but the company is taking proactive steps to mitigate the risk.

Google’s Strategic Response

According to internal meetings with Google executives like Liz Reid, Vidhya Srinivasan, and Nick Fox, the company is considering different outcomes for the future of Search. Fox outlined three possible scenarios: maintaining Search’s dominance, losing traffic to Gemini, or losing traffic to ChatGPT. The preferred scenario is to keep Search strong, but there’s also a clear recognition that the rise of AI-driven platforms like Gemini is something Google needs to prepare for.

Monetizing Gemini and Preparing for the Shift

Srinivasan, in particular, stressed the urgency of monetizing Gemini, highlighting the importance of moving quickly to integrate ads into the platform. In Alphabet’s recent earnings call, there were hints that Gemini could evolve into a new advertising platform, which would help Google remain competitive.

Connecting Search with Gemini

Rather than seeing Gemini as a direct competitor to Search, Google is exploring ways to create a connected strategy that allows both platforms to work together. This could include integrating more advanced shopping solutions and ensuring a smoother transition between Search and Gemini for users.

Speculation on Performance Drops in the Agency Landscape

Some agencies have seen performance drops recently, and it's important to consider whether these declines are tied to market jitters due to external factors, such as tariffs, or if they’re more related to the growing influence of AI in the search space. It could very well be a combination of both.

Market Jitters:

Economic uncertainty, including concerns over tariffs and shifting market conditions, might be causing businesses to tighten their marketing budgets. When companies are unsure about future revenue, they tend to scale back on advertising spend, which can lead to performance drops. Additionally, in periods of economic instability, consumer spending habits often shift, which could result in lower engagement and conversions.

AI Impact:

The increasing use of AI-powered search engines like ChatGPT and Gemini is also changing the landscape. As more users turn to AI tools for direct, conversational answers, traditional search methods may see less engagement. This shift is reflected in the growing use of platforms like ChatGPT, which now commands 80% of the AI search traffic. For businesses relying on traditional search engine traffic, this could impact click-through rates and conversions. The decline in traditional search traffic, combined with AI-driven tools offering faster, more personalized answers, could be contributing to recent performance declines.

Staying Bold and Fearless Amid Uncertainty

In times of uncertainty, it’s tempting to pull back and scale down efforts, but this is when big wins often emerge for those who stay bold and fearless. While others may be scaling back their campaigns or reducing their spend in response to economic pressures or AI shifts, this is an opportunity to innovate, double down on what works, and embrace new strategies. Companies that adapt quickly and strategically can still gain significant advantages, even in challenging times. The key is to remain focused, continue optimizing campaigns, and seize opportunities that others may overlook.

Looking Ahead

While Google’s dominance in search remains secure for now, the company is smartly preparing for the future. With the rise of AI technologies, Google is positioning itself to adapt and remain a key player in the search and advertising space. By focusing on Gemini and its potential as both a search tool and ad platform, Google is laying the groundwork for a future where AI plays a much larger role in the way we search for information online.

As the landscape continues to evolve, Google's ability to adapt to these changes will be key to maintaining its leadership position in search and advertising.

Get Ahead of Missed Opportunities

If you’re concerned about missing out on key opportunities, now is the time to take action. I offer complimentary audits to assess whether your current strategies are fully optimized and aligned with the latest market shifts. Let’s work together to ensure your business is positioned for success—don’t let uncertainty hold you back from achieving big wins.

Feel free to reach out and schedule your complimentary audit today!